Canadian DMCA
Peter Jackson film adaptation of The Lord of the Rings opens thusly:
The world is changed. I feel it in the water. I feel it in the Earth. I smell it in the air. Much that once was is lost. For none now hold the copyright to profit from it.
Okay, I paraphrased that last bit, but I think it speaks to the mindset of copyright litigators who see copyright, not as an protection of creative ownership, but as the spigot from which profit pours freely. Over the past 50 years, copyright has changed from being a protection of commodities and instead become a commodity in and of itself.
Yet the ever-evolving world of technology and communications refuses to be bound by that vision of copyright, just as it refused such visions during the birth of the magnetic cassette tape, the VCR, the writable CD and the now-ubiquitous digital media device (eg: iPod). There are two ways of addressing such conflict. Either a) legislate the vision into law, or b) change the vision. Canada is now in the process of joining the US by opting for option a, introducing it’s own Canuckian version of the US’s Digital Millennium Copyright Act, and opinion is much divided. While I support the concept of protecting one’s copyright, these laws designed to permit vigilante justice on the part of copyright holders just don’t address the REAL issue which is simply this: the world has changed. You either change with it, or cease to exist. Criminalizing emergent ever-evolving technology has never worked and it will never work.
Thoughts?


